Position：home

The Islanders vs. Blues: Comparing Two Distinct NHL Franchises

The National Hockey League's (NHL) two most decorated franchises, the New York Islanders and the St. Louis Blues, have a storied history marked by contrasting achievements and unique identities. This comprehensive analysis provides an in-depth comparison of these legendary teams, exploring their milestones, rosters, statistics, and impact on the sport.

Historical Overview

The Islanders were founded in 1972 as an expansion team, quickly rising to prominence with four consecutive Stanley Cup championships from 1980 to 1983. Led by legendary players such as Mike Bossy, Bryan Trottier, and Billy Smith, the team became synonymous with the "dynasty" era.

The Blues joined the NHL in 1967 and gradually established themselves as a formidable force in the Western Conference. After decades of playoff appearances, their breakthrough came in 2019 when they captured their first Stanley Cup, ending a 52-year title drought. Led by Vladimir Tarasenko, Ryan O'Reilly, and Jordan Binnington, the Blues have emerged as a consistent playoff contender.

islanders vs blues

Roster Comparison

Offense:

Position	Islanders	Blues
Center	Mathew Barzal, Brock Nelson	Ryan O'Reilly, Robert Thomas
Left Wing	Anders Lee, Anthony Beauvillier	Vladimir Tarasenko, Brandon Saad
Right Wing	Kyle Palmieri, Zach Parise	Pavel Buchnevich, Jordan Kyrou

Defense:

The Islanders vs. Blues: Comparing Two Distinct NHL Franchises

Position	Islanders	Blues
Defenseman	Ryan Pulock, Adam Pelech	Torey Krug, Justin Faulk
Defenseman	Noah Dobson, Alexander Romanov	Robert Bortuzzo, Calle Rosen

Goaltending:

Historical Overview

Position	Islanders	Blues
Goaltender	Ilya Sorokin, Semyon Varlamov	Jordan Binnington, Thomas Greiss

Statistical Comparison

According to NHL data, the Islanders have maintained a slightly higher winning percentage (0.580) than the Blues (0.572) over the past five seasons. However, the Blues have a more impressive playoff record, reaching the Stanley Cup Final twice in that time frame compared to the Islanders' one appearance in the Eastern Conference Final.

Offensive Statistics:

Category	Islanders	Blues
Goals per game	3.27	3.46
Power play percentage	21.6%	20.1%
Penalty kill percentage	81.7%	77.4%

Defensive Statistics:

Category	Islanders	Blues
Goals against per game	2.72	2.60
Save percentage	0.918	0.915
Penalty minutes per game	11.4	10.3

Why It Matters

The Islanders and Blues provide contrasting models of success in the NHL. The Islanders represent a classic example of a team that dominated an era through sheer skill and consistency, while the Blues embody the resilience and determination required to overcome adversity and achieve ultimate triumph.

Benefits of the Comparison

Analyzing these two teams provides valuable insights into:

The different paths to NHL success
The importance of team chemistry and leadership
The evolution of playing styles and tactics

Call to Action

Whether you are an ardent Islanders or Blues fan, or simply a hockey enthusiast, this detailed comparison offers a better understanding of these iconic franchises and their contributions to the sport. Embrace the rivalry, appreciate the differences, and continue to support the storied tradition of NHL hockey.