10 of Rockaway's Best Restaurants for 2025

Situated on the Jersey Shore, Rockaway is a vibrant town with a thriving culinary scene. From casual eateries to upscale dining experiences, there's something to satisfy every palate in this charming seaside destination. In anticipation of the upcoming year, we've curated a list of the top 10 restaurants in Rockaway, each offering a unique blend of flavors and ambiance.

1. The Lobster House

Cuisine: American Seafood

Price Range: $$$$

Must-Try Dish: Lobster Roll

Established in 1946, The Lobster House is a Rockaway institution known for its fresh seafood and stunning ocean views. The menu features an array of lobster dishes, including broiled, boiled, and their signature lobster roll. With its elegant atmosphere and attentive service, The Lobster House is perfect for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.

2. Mikado's Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar

Cuisine: Japanese

Price Range: $$

Must-Try Dish: Sushi Platter

Mikado's offers a lively dining experience with skilled chefs preparing hibachi-style meals right at your table. The extensive sushi menu features traditional and creative rolls, all made with the freshest ingredients. The sleek and modern interior creates a cozy atmosphere for a memorable dining experience.

3. Daddy O's Brick Oven Pizza

Cuisine: Italian

Price Range: $

Must-Try Dish: The Works Pizza

For a casual and family-friendly dining option, head to Daddy O's Brick Oven Pizza. Their wood-fired pizzas are legendary in Rockaway, with a crispy crust and generous toppings. The menu also includes a variety of pasta dishes, salads, and sandwiches.

4. The Black Whale

Cuisine: American

Price Range: $$

Must-Try Dish: Blackened Salmon

The Black Whale is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike, serving a diverse menu with a focus on American comfort food. Their blackened salmon is a must-try, as well as their juicy burgers and savory pasta dishes. The lively atmosphere and friendly service make The Black Whale a great place to go with friends or family.

5. Sunset Bay Cafe

Cuisine: International

Price Range: $$

Must-Try Dish: Seafood Paella

Sunset Bay Cafe offers a global dining experience with flavors from around the world. Their seafood paella is a highlight, featuring a vibrant medley of seafood, rice, and aromatic spices. The cozy and intimate atmosphere is perfect for a romantic getaway or a casual lunch.

6. Nunzio's Pizza & Italian Kitchen

Cuisine: Italian

Price Range: $

Must-Try Dish: Italian Meatball Parmigiana

For authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Nunzio's Pizza & Italian Kitchen. Their hearty meatball parmigiana is a crowd-pleaser, as well as their classic pizzas and homemade pasta dishes. The friendly staff and casual atmosphere create a warm and inviting dining experience.

7. Clam Broth House

Cuisine: Seafood

Price Range: $

Must-Try Dish: Clam Chowder

The Clam Broth House is a Rockaway institution, famous for its creamy and flavorful clam chowder. Their steamed clams and raw oysters are also popular choices, served fresh daily. The no-frills atmosphere is perfect for a quick and satisfying seafood meal.

8. The Sandbox

Cuisine: American

Price Range: $$

Must-Try Dish: Lobster Mac & Cheese

The Sandbox is a beachy-casual restaurant with a creative menu and a lively atmosphere. Their lobster mac & cheese is a signature dish, blending rich cheese sauce with succulent lobster. The outdoor patio offers stunning views of the ocean, making The Sandbox a great spot for a relaxing meal or a night out with friends.

9. Kennedy's Pub

Cuisine: American Pub Food

Price Range: $

Must-Try Dish: Shepherd's Pie

Kennedy's Pub is a cozy and friendly establishment serving classic American pub food. Their shepherd's pie is a hearty and comforting dish, perfect for a chilly night. The pub atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with a wide selection of beer on tap.

10. The Salty Dog

Cuisine: American Seafood

Price Range: $$

Must-Try Dish: Seafood Platter

The Salty Dog is a seafood shack serving fresh catches of the day and classic seafood dishes. Their seafood platter is a feast for the senses, featuring a variety of seafood favorites. The casual and laid-back atmosphere is perfect for a casual lunch or a sunset dinner with a view.

Conclusion

Rockaway's culinary scene offers a diverse range of dining experiences, from fine dining to casual and family-friendly options. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, juicy burgers, savory pasta, or exotic international flavors, you'll find it all in this charming seaside town. As you plan your dining adventures in Rockaway, be sure to check out our list of the top 10 restaurants and discover the gastronomic delights that await you. Bon appétit!

Hot Search Title: Top Rockaway Restaurants 2025: A Culinary Journey by the Shore

Useful Tables: